Recent Content

Dear Pascal: My Friend Sends 9 Minute Voice Memos

Dear Pascal: My Friend Sends 9 Minute Voice Memos

Post

Pascal answers a reader whose friend needs nine minutes of voice memo to confirm lunch, with Provincial Letters wisdom on why short takes work.

Everybody's Got Something

Everybody's Got Something

Post

Robin Roberts' blunt reminder that everyone carries hidden struggles shows why resilience starts with honesty about your own.

Give Up What Weighs You Down

Give Up What Weighs You Down

Post

Toni Morrison's blunt advice on flight and freedom shows why letting go, not adding more, is what actually gets you moving.

Dear Mary Wollstonecraft: My Grown Kids Talk Over Me

Dear Mary Wollstonecraft: My Grown Kids Talk Over Me

Post

Mary Wollstonecraft on being dismissed at your own table.

The Five People Who Shape You

The Five People Who Shape You

Post

Jim Rohn's blunt theory on influence shows why the people you spend time with quietly shape who you become.

See All Content
logo
  • Success & Leadership
  • Mindfulness & Peace
  • Love & Relationships
  • Personal Growth
  • Creativity & Purpose
  • Resilience & Courage
  • About Us
  • Success & Leadership
  • Mindfulness & Peace
  • Love & Relationships
  • Personal Growth
  • Creativity & Purpose
  • Resilience & Courage
  • About Us
  • ​

Dear Cicero: My In Laws Have A Family Thread Without Me

Cicero considers the modern family group chat and finds it wanting in the department of actual friendship.
Ancient Wisdom, Modern Problem

My In Laws Have A Family Thread Without Me

Dear Cicero,

I have been married into this family for seventeen years, and I just found out there is a group text called Fam Only that does not include me, only my husband and his three siblings. They plan Thanksgiving logistics, swap photos, and apparently debate who got the good stuffing recipe, all without me. I found out because my husband laughed at his phone at dinner and would not say why. Am I overreacting, or is this a real slight?

— Threadless in Tulsa

Cicero Replies

Marcus Tullius Cicero, Roman statesman, orator, and philosopher (106 to 43 BC)

Dear Threadless in Tulsa,

Threadless in Tulsa, I have spent a great deal of my life thinking about friendship, and I can tell you this much freely: a name on a chat thread means nothing. A door closed to you after seventeen years of dinners and births and holidays means a great deal more. But perhaps not in the way you fear.

The deeper question is not who included you, but what you believe inclusion proves. True family, like true friendship, is not a list of names on a message. As I wrote in my work on friendship, a friend is, as it were, a second self. If you are a second self to this family, no thread can confirm or deny it, and no thread can take it away.

So do not campaign for admission to the Fam Only thread like a general laying siege to a minor fort. Instead, build the thing the thread is only a symbol of. Call your sister-in-law directly about something small, a recipe, a joke, a complaint about your husband. Real bonds are made in these ordinary exchanges, not granted by inclusion in a digital circle.

This week, pick one in-law and start a private, easy conversation with them, no agenda, just warmth. Let the thread exist without you. A second self does not need a seat at every table to know she belongs at this one.

— Cicero

In Cicero's Own Words

“A friend is, as it were, a second self.”

— Cicero, On Friendship

In this work, Cicero explores what makes friendship different from mere acquaintance or utility, arguing true friends share virtue and affection so completely that each becomes an extension of the other. The line captures his belief that genuine bonds are internal and chosen, not dependent on outside recognition. It applies neatly to any modern worry about being formally included versus truly belonging.

Who Was Cicero?

Marcus Tullius Cicero was a Roman statesman, lawyer, and philosopher whose speeches and letters shaped Latin prose for centuries. He served as consul, survived political exile, and was eventually executed for opposing Mark Antony. His philosophical dialogues, including On Friendship and On Old Age, written late in life, blend Greek philosophy with practical Roman wisdom. He remains one of the most quoted authors in the Western tradition.

Try This Today

Today, reach out to one family member outside your usual small talk and ask about something specific to them, a hobby, a project, an opinion they hold strongly. Skip the group chat entirely. The goal is one real exchange, not visibility, and real exchanges build belonging faster than any thread invitation ever could.

Your Turn

If no one ever added you to the list, what would you still do to show up for this family anyway?

LOVE AND RELATIONSHIPS
BELONGING
HUMOR

Letters are composites written by the Lifted Words editors. Replies are written in the spirit of each thinker; the quote in the blue box is their own.

Terms and ConditionsDo Not Sell or Share My Personal InformationPrivacy PolicyPrivacy NoticeAccessibility NoticeUnsubscribe
Copyright © 2026 Inspirational Quotes